Brief Ruminations on Spanish Anti-Cruelty Laws

While writing the syllabus for the comparative criminal law seminar that I will teach in Buenos Aires this September, I stumbled upon Spain’s anti-cruelty statutes. It seems that in Spain it’s only a crime to mistreat companion animals (Art. 337 of Spanish Penal Code) or unjustifiably inflict pain on non-companion animals pursuant to a public show or sporting event (Art. 632(2) of Spanish Penal Code). Therefore, it seems that, contrary to what I have argued is the case in the United States, Spain’s anti-cruelty statutes do not seek to protect the animal itself from cruel mistreatment. Rather, the goal of Spanish cruelty laws appears to be the protection of those with close emotional ties to the mistreated animal or those who witness the infliction of unjustifiable harm on the creatures. Furthermore, at first glance, it appears that Spanish cruelty statutes protect animals less than their American counterparts, for unjustifiably mistreating non-companion animals is a crime in many, if not all, states regardless of whether it takes place in public or private.

I wonder why Spain’s legislature decided to limit the scope of Art. 632(2) by requiring that the mistreatment occur in public.  Perhaps it was meant to ban animal fighting. This would seem rather odd, though, as it clearly was not intended to ban bullfighting and, given that dogs are companion animals,  dog fighting would be a crime pursuant to Art. 337 if the dogs are significantly harmed as a result of the event.  Do any of our Spanish readers know the answer to this question?

Luis Chiesa

One Response

  1. Very well done Luis. I am a PhD candidate teaching International Law at Florida International University and I was wondering why doesn’t Spain have to comply with the Statutes of the EU regarding animal cruelty? It it this mandatory? I am also a proud mommy of two whippets (from the greyhound family) and I am have been terrified, completely shocked by the level of suffering, torture and slaughter these dogs are submitted to in Spain (hanging, burned alive, starvation, abandonment…). Since they are not pets, but hunting dogs they are not entitled to protection. This is absurd. Is there anything that can be done? Legally, I mean…What do you think?
    Thank you,
    Warmly,
    Ana Podcameni

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: