James Coolidge Carter on The Rapaciousness of Humanity

David Cassuto

James Coolidge Carter was arguably the preeminent appellate advocate of his time (he lived from 1828-1905 and was at the height of his fame at the end of the 19th century.  A Mugwump, he had strong principled views on the human condition and a tenacious belief in the beauty of the economic order.  The system’s fucntioning required the best of human traits to prevail in the never-ending battle between good and evil.  Yet, Coolidge was remarkably skeptical of the innate goodness of humanity, writing:

The brute cares only for the wants of his body, and when these are satisfied he lies down contented . . . . But the desires of man have no such limitations.  However much he may acquire, he is still greedy for more, and is never satisfied.

It struck me reading this that this sentiment is probably widely shared, even among those who routinely subordinate and brutalize nonhumans while  justifying their actions on the grounds that the victims are “only animals.”  Of course, this is not a new insight nor was it Coolidge’s point (he was not addressing human/nonhuman relationships at all).  However, it got me thinking.  Today it occured to me for the first time that expecting selfish, anti-social behavior from humans while comparing ourselves disfavorably to “brutes” simulataneously enables both critical self-reflection and ongoing exploitation.  In that sense, self-criticism absent any accompanying will to reform is powerfully anti-social. 

h/t to Lewis Grossman, whose interesting chapter on Coolidge sent me off on this tangent.

One Response

  1. I do not understand how “expecting selfish, anti-social behavior from humans while comparing ourselves disfavorably to “brutes” simulataneously enables” self reflection. Doesnt it limit self reflection? But I understand how it facilitates ongoing exploitation.

    Your line of thinking got me thinking about all the eco-conscious/philanthropists who worked FOR the environment this past summer or worked FOR public interest this past summer who are now applying to work in corporate law or to defend big polluters “just to see what the other side is like.”

    “The desires of man have no such limitations” when it comes to building a resume.

    I guess Brutes stick with the causes they have a passion for.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: