Myths, More than Traditional Medicine, Driving Rhino Slaughter

 Andrew C. Revkin

x-post from Dot Earth

Rhino horns seized by Customs in Hong Kong

Rhinoceros populations from Asia through Africa are plummeting in the face of burgeoning illicit trade in their horns, much of it driven by myths promoted by criminal smuggling syndicates and targeting the new wealthy in China and Vietnam. The Green blog and Dot Earth have explored these issues, but it’s worth a slightly deeper dive, here provided in a “Your Dot” contribution from Matthew Wilkinson, the founder and editor of the informative Safaritalk blog.

Here’s an excerpt and link to the full essay by Wilkinson, which I’ve posted via

Matt Wilkinson: As someone who devotes his days to highlighting wildlife conservation in Africa, when I’m asked to name my greatest concern, without hesitation I say the poaching onslaught devastating rhinoceros populations. With so many pressing problems besetting wildlife and the environment, why this one issue over and above everything else? The answer is shaped by the shocking way in which the rhinos are killed and their horns removed, the widespread myths fueling the recent poaching escalation and the apparent inability of governments to tackle this massive problem with anything approaching competence.

In South Africa as of mid October, 439 rhinos had been killed so far in 2012. That is only 9 short of last year’s total, and 432 more than the 7 reported in 2000. Throughout Africa, on average 50 rhinos are killed for their horns each month – and of course that doesn’t include the losses of Indian, Sumatran and Javan rhinos, whose numbers are plummeting. Despite public awareness campaigns, worldwide petitions, increasing press coverage and pressure on African governments, and large amounts of money donated to rhino conservation groups, the slaughter accelerates. So, why is it still happening?

Use of rhino horn in Traditional Chinese Medicine [TCM below] and Traditional Oriental Medicine dates back centuries. In a recent Safaritalk article, a retired practitioner of traditional Chinese medicine described the horn’s allure this way: “The character of rhino horn is very cool and is used for curing the heat. The character of the remedy brings the healing; rhino horn is cool, salty, bitter. Viruses create heat (high temperature), and because ancient medicine didn’t know about bacteria, they would use the character of the illness for diagnosis and treatment.” He went on to say, “Rhino horn would clear the heat in the blood and de-toxify the blood in the body. It is also used to treat conditions causing the blood to ‘go the wrong way,’ such as nosebleed. Only a small amount of horn is used, mixed with the other ingredients (herbs, gypsum) or tea.” But since 1993 trade in rhino horn, (as well as tiger parts) was banned by the Chinese government with the aim of stopping the use of endangered wildlife derivatives in TCM: but advocates cling to historical evidence, knowing their ancestors used it, their parents, grandparents: the reason why it continues to be used today by many Chinese families. “As far as the manner of the death and suffering of an animal; to an un-educated Chinese as long as a medicine can save children they don’t care where it comes from,” stated the practitioner to Safaritalk.

Alternative traditional cures exist which are proven to work, are not derived from rhinos, (or any other animal), and are much cheaper to buy. The practitioner says in the article that his mother used to dig roots, adding, “You don’t have to use rhino horn.” And leafing through an ancient Chinese medical textbook he showed there to be over 500 different herbs in addition to animal remedies and stressed there are “botanical TCM substitutes for rhino horn, and… that’s what people should concentrate on.”

So instead of demonizing traditional Asian medical practices solely based on the use of rhino horn, it’s time greater emphasis is placed upon promoting these herbal alternatives. With perfectly valid and cost effective herbal remedies, who exactly is benefiting from the trade in the prohibitively expensive rhino horn? Surely not the end user.

Rhino Horn as Cancer Cure and Club Drug

So while reliance on rhino horn in Asian medicine may be on a gradual decline (although much slower than is necessary for the survival of the world’s five rhino species), a more immediate threat is posed from two newly developing markets for rhino horn: spurious media reports of its miraculous cancer-curing properties (no doubt propaganda on the part of those fuelling demand) and a frightening rise in the demand for horn as a statement of wealth and affluence. [Read the rest.]

Also notable is the recent blog in which the Chinese basketball star Yao Ming, working with the nonprofit group WildAid, tracked his trip along the horn and ivory trail to Africa.

3 Responses

  1. I knew about — and am thankful for — Yao Ming’s dedication to showing the Chinese people the cruel exploitation of sharks for their fins and the merciless poaching of elephants for their ivory tusks.

    But I didn’t know Yao was also trying to raise awareness of the devastating rhino slaughter. So thank you, Andrew, for bringing it to our attention and for posting the interview with an expert on the subject, Matthew Wilkinson.

  2. As long as there’s money to be made…

  3. I suppose that rhino horns used for medical “cures” stem from ancient ignorance to what modern medicine (and traditional plant based medicine) can heal…

    But in the case of ivory – This must be sheer gluttony compounded by ignorance. Isn’t all the ivory used for vain ornament?

    I’m thrilled that just yesterday: “The authorities in Hong Kong have intercepted one of the largest shipments of illegal ivory in history.”

    I hope we can turn the tide in time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: